May 18, 2023

Overcoming the Blockchain Trilemma: A Dive into Layer 1 and Layer 2 Solutions

The Balance Ecosystem encompasses a wide range of innovative products and developments in various DeFi and Web3 technology areas.
Balance is poised to build bridges between the theoretical and practical sides of finance so that there is a means in which we can provide real-world solutions and create value driven products within the web3 space.

Balance Capital

The emergence of blockchain technology has brought the potential for massive transformation across industries. However, every innovative solution comes with its unique challenges, and for blockchain, it's the infamous trilemma. This trilemma refers to the difficulty of achieving scalability, security, and decentralization simultaneously. In today's post, we will explore how Layer 1 and Layer 2 solutions provide innovative approaches to this conundrum.

Balancing Act: The Blockchain Trilemma

Every blockchain aims for three vital attributes – decentralization (no central authority), security (resistance to attacks), and scalability (capacity to handle increasing workload). However, enhancing one aspect often leads to compromises in the other two. This trade-off is what we refer to as the blockchain trilemma.

The solution lies in novel architectural designs and strategies, namely Layer 1 and Layer 2 solutions, which strive to strike a balance between these elements.

Reengineering the Core: Layer 1 Solutions

Layer 1 solutions refer to enhancements made to the blockchain protocol itself. Let's examine a few examples:

Increasing Block Size: Increasing the size of each block allows more transactions to be processed at once. This directly increases the transaction processing capacity of the blockchain.

Increasing Block Confirmation Rate: The faster a block is confirmed, the quicker the transactions are validated. A higher confirmation rate can lead to improved scalability.

Sharding: Sharding breaks down the blockchain into smaller parts, or "shards". Each shard processes transactions independently, thus boosting the transaction processing capacity.

Changing Consensus Mechanism: Transitioning from Proof of Work (PoW) to Proof of Stake (PoS) can significantly enhance efficiency. While PoW demands substantial computational power, PoS chooses validators based on their economic stake in the network, saving resources and increasing speed.

Ethereum’s upgrade to PoS, for instance, is a prime example of a Layer 1 solution.

Lightening the Load: Layer 2 Solutions

Layer 2 solutions operate on top of the main blockchain, offloading some of the transactional load. These solutions help boost transaction processing capacity without sacrificing decentralization or security.

For instance, the Lightning Network for Bitcoin and Polygon for Ethereum are popular Layer 2 solutions. They process transactions off-chain before finalizing them on the main chain, greatly enhancing scalability.

Will One Chain Rule Them All?

While these solutions are promising, the perfect balance among the three aspects of the trilemma still eludes us. It's crucial to remember that these aspects exist on a spectrum, and each blockchain project may prioritize differently based on its specific requirements.

Projects like Ethereum and Cardano are pioneering this approach by leveraging both Layer 1 and Layer 2 solutions. Ethereum has a $33.9 billion stake and a block time of 12-14 seconds, while Cardano has a $24.12 billion stake with a block time of 20 seconds.

Meanwhile, Solana, Terra, and Avalanche are other noteworthy projects tackling the trilemma in unique ways. Solana, for instance, has a staggering 74.71% of its total coin supply staked, 1,789 validators, and an impressive 1,212 transactions per second (TPS).


The blockchain trilemma is a complex problem, but the innovative solutions being developed give us reason to be optimistic. Layer 1 and Layer 2 solutions, each with their unique strengths, provide promising paths towards a future where blockchains can achieve the trifecta of decentralization.